Rate the Episode!!!

[Pippi]

I quite liked this episode. A little bit more 'classic Lost'

Liked:
Juliet flipping Kate. That was cool. Where'd the Others learn to fight like that?
Smokey (and his polaroid camera, lol)
Kate's flashback - wasn't a bad one, I thought. Not usually a fan, but this one was ok. If only Cassidy had said 'Sawyer'!
Creepy Locke - what's going on?
Sayid lives! Yay!
The Hurley/Sawyer story - didn't mind it. It was slightly lame but still amusing to watch.

Didn't like:
Idiot Jack - wake up and smell the coffee, buddy! The Others are bad
Smokey getting stopped by the fence. That was just stupid after we saw Kate climbing over it. Wonder how they'll explain that one?
The mud scene - whatever


My favourite line this week came (surprisingly) from Juliet (who is fast becoming my favourite character):

Kate: How's your shoulder?
Juliet: Awesome.

Made me giggle

[lostinlaf]

I think it was a great episode, but I only gave it an 8 b/c it didn't have the shock effect that some episodes have. But still a great episode.

[so original]

I liked this episode. Hurley making Sawyer be nice was pretty funny.

[freckles_shephard]

Enjoyed the episode. Kate and Juliet were great. Flashbacks were good too, more pre island connections!

[thelizinator297]

A great episode, nine in my book. I loved Hurley's manipulation of Sawyer--it was too funny! I was also pretty impressed by Juliet's ability to throw someone over her shoulder. The Juliet/Kate dynamics were interesting. I found the flashbacks frustrating, just because I feel like even if you love someone, something is wrong with your relationship if they come home and beat someone. It makes what Kate did seem rash (I think it was anyways). Also loved the ending (I love Lost partially because they know how to end an eppy).

[mrsx]

it's one of my favourite episodes so far!
hurley and sawyer made me laugh
flashback was cool too, because we've got more connections and smokie is a little bit dumb because it's not flying over the fence
Juliet is awesome ^^

[RipperJack]

We have a revelation about the Monster in this episode. Leaving us to believe that maybe the sonic fence was not only to keep out the Hostiles, but many other "strange" inhabitants of the island
.